Latinos battle for more recognition in war film
Sunday, August 5, 2007
By LAWRENCE AARON RECORD COLUMNIST
|
|
NO WINNER has been declared in the war between Ken Burns and the Latino community over his seven-part epic called "The War."
Leaving out Latino contributions to World War II was bad enough.
Adding a sprinkle of interviews to the finished product doesn't even
begin to bolster the story enough to appease the critics.
The dispute about Burns' omission of Latinos from his
soon-to-be-aired documentary seemed to be moving toward a resolution in
the spring after talks were held with PBS executives and the filmmaker.
Rep. Albio Sires, D-West New York, added his voice to the outraged
tone in a Congressional Hispanic Caucus letter criticizing the PBS
decision to air the World War II documentary that ignores the
contribution of at least half a million Latinos.
Burns made a reluctant about-face, adding on-camera interviews to
the ends of three episodes. Two of the three new veterans who tell
their stories are Latino and one is Native American.
A spokesman for Burns' film, Joe DePlasco, says the
15-hour film is unchanged except for the interviews, which added half
an hour. DePlasco carefully emphasized that the interviews appear
before the credits roll at the end of the episodes.
Burns' solution is only OK: He can do better. No one could
realistically ask him to completely reedit the series before it airs in
September. But records and images were available for a deeper look at
Latinos' contribution to the war effort.
History overlooks Latinos
History in general overlooks Latino military men, says Noemi
Figueroa Soulet, who found great archival footage for "The
Borinqueneers," a film about Puerto Rico's 65th Infantry Regiment.
"This is another example -- like the Tuskegee airmen, the
Japanese-American Nisei unit, the Buffalo Soldiers -- of minority
military contributions. I just wanted to add to the Latino chapter of
this history." Her film airs this week on NJN and WNET-13 television.
Instead of doing just enough to silence the critics, Burns could
take the high road and work with aspiring Latino film students to
create an hour-long film exploring the missing pieces. The Latino
community shouldn't have to work this hard to get recognition. Twelve
of them got the Congressional Medal of Honor as soldiers.
The controversy started when a University of Texas journalism
professor, Maggie Rivas-Rodriguez, found holes in Burns' concept while
working on an oral history project.
Rivas-Rodriguez is steaming over his attempt to simply throw them a
bone. Here, gnaw on this and stop barking. It's not about just tacking
on a few interviews, she said, pointing to a richer heritage of Latino
contributions to World War II -- military and non-military.
Allies supplied her with anecdotes like the one about a worker named
Alvarado, who was deported in the 1940s. He got his draft notice in
Mexico, fought at Normandy, became a German prisoner of war, and ended
up coming back to father 14 kids in America. Ten of them joined the
military.
Rivas-Rodriguez' own recollections are rich in detail specific to
Latin culture. Burns' project ignores civilian contributions like her
mother's.
"They worked in factories. They were Rosita the Riveter," she said.
"My mother was in San Antonio at Kelly Air Force Base ... and they
worked on some of the instruments that were used on the airplanes.
"The Latino experience is deep and rich," Rivas-Rodriguez said.
"The reason this issue has really resonated with Latinos across the
board is it isn't only a Mexican-American issue, it is very much a
Puerto Rican issue, a Cuban-American -- every ethnicity that's
considered Latino has some experience with this and feels very strongly
about it."
Suspicion
Mobilizing the troops here in the East, Angelo Falcón, president and
founder of the National Institute for Latino Policy, feels that PBS and
Burns' people haven't been dealing in good faith.
"There's a lot of suspicion," said Falcón. "He gets a lot of money
for his proposals full of talk about diversity....We're not trying to
change his point of view; we're trying to get him to be inclusive."
Falcón feels like he's under attack, fending off accusations that
his side is trying to censor Burns' material. The balance of power
seems to shift with each skirmish. The winner has yet to be determined.
Lawrence Aaron is a Record columnist. Contact him at
aaron@northjersey.com. Send comments about this column to
letterstotheeditor@northjersey.com.
|