Latino Groups Still at War With Ken Burns, PBS
By Yoji Cole

©
DiversityInc 2007 ® All rights reserved. No article on this site can be
reproduced by any means, print, electronic or any other, without prior written permission of the
publisher.
Date Posted: August 21, 2007
Latino-advocacy
organizations are angry that "The War," a seven-part documentary that
tells the story of World War II, only features 28 minutes of interviews
from Latinos and that producers screened a copy without the additional
Latino footage.
"The
War," which will air on the Public Broadcasting Service (PBS) Sept. 23,
is being directed and produced by Ken Burns and Lynn Novick, who have
14.5 hours of footage including interviews with World War II veterans
and their families from towns across the nation. Not enough of that
footage includes Latinos, say Latino leaders.
PBS's web site features two clips of Burns' footage. Out of eight interviews, the two clips feature only one person of color, a Japanese American.
"Since
the issue was first raised earlier this year, PBS and Ken Burns have
met and corresponded with a range of organizations from the Latino
community ... We
are pleased that [Burns], HACR [Hispanic Association on Corporate
Responsibility], and the American GI Forum were able to reach an
agreement in May about the new content. PBS feels that Ken's
willingness to add content after the completion of his production is
highly commendable," said Lea Sloan, vice president of communications
for PBS.
In
addition to HACR, Latino groups such as the Congressional Hispanic
Caucus, Defend the Honor and the National Council of La Raza (NCLR) in
January criticized Burns and PBS for the absence of Latinos in the
series. The issue appeared resolved, however, in April when NCLR
announced Burns would include footage from a Latino World War II
documentarian.
But
the issue was not resolved. Defend the Honor, a group that seeks to
preserve the legacy of Latinos in World War II, reported Monday that
"key Latino organizations and leaders across the country today publicly
announced that the issue is far from resolved and that they will
continue pressing for a respectful resolution."
"It's
just two interviews ... we want to see how they have interwoven that
into the overall documentary and see what else they have done to
represent the Latino experience," said Gus Chavez, a member of Defend
the Honor's core group and a retired administrator of San Diego State
University.
Defend
the Honor is also upset because it says Burns has been dismissive of
the arguments that the inclusion of Latinos is about historical
accuracy rather than political correctness.
"In
the political world, where I don't exist, people use rhetoric and yell
at each other. I wanted to be above that. Politics, for me, has always
been a small p. I like to see the larger, more complicated thing," said
Burns to the Philadelphia Inquirer.
"It
is unfortunate that Ken Burns continues to see this issue as one of
politics and rhetoric that he must rise above," said Maggie
Rivas-Rodríguez, co-chair of Defend the Honor. "It has nothing to do
with politics and everything to do with historical accuracy and
inclusion."
Defend
the Honor says Burns and PBS did not allow them or representatives from
the Television Critics Association (TCA) to review the additional
footage. TCA critics were provided an advance copy of the series;
however, it came without the new material that includes Latino
interviews and one Native American interview.
"Without
access to the new material, television critics could not evaluate it
and ask questions in open forum at their meeting with Ken Burns,
associate producer Lynn Novick and PBS CEO and President Paula Kerger,"
read a statement from Defend the Honor.
Sloan's statement, however, reports that "The War" was screened with the Latino footage included.
"[Burns]
has scheduled many screenings in recent months, including one in June
at the Library of Congress, attended by representatives of Latino
groups, where clips from the new content were shown in rough-cut form,"
said Sloan. "In August, the American GI forum invited [Burns] to show
clips from 'The War' at their annual conference. That screening
included clips of the new content featuring Latino veterans of WWII and
the featured vets appeared at the conference in person."
"To
us, two interviews with Latino veterans does not represent the Latino
World War II experience," says Chavez. "And that's what we've been
asking for since the beginning of the campaign in early January."
More Free Diversity News >>
|